Day in the life of an Expert Witness

Our day in the life series provides examples of the kind of work undertaken by our members across a range of different professional backgrounds.

A Day in the Life of a Flooring Expert Witness
Emma Mitra 2

A Day in the Life of a Flooring Expert Witness

by Emma Mitra

 

Rob Kilner has spent nearly 30 years in the flooring industry, running his own contracting and restoration business across the UK. He founded Flooring Inspector to provide Expert Witness services on flooring disputes. He tells us about swapping tools for writing Expert reports, the importance of honesty and attention to detail, and why he relishes the justice of the work.

I've been in the flooring industry since I left school.

Whether it was commercial work or domestic jobs, I've always been contracting. Over time, though, I realised I needed to do something different. The industry changed a lot from how it was when I started, and I got to the point where I didn't want to be contracting for another 30 years.

Expert Witness work was always a gap in this market that I thought I could fill.

There were a few well-known characters in the flooring industry known as ‘pens for hire’. I always thought that if I became an Expert Witness, I wouldn't care who was paying for the report – I would say what's actually going on, rather than what someone's paid to hear.

For me, the motivation to become an Expert was a combination of wanting to do something else, without changing industry completely, and being able to do the job the way I think it should be done. I got my first instructions about 18 months ago and haven’t looked back.

Rob KilnerAs an Expert Witness practice, we’ve got national coverage.

I run Flooring Inspector with my business partner Tom, who I've known for 25 years, and our consultant Hugo. I'm based in Surrey, Tom's in Darlington and Hugo's in South Wales, which gives us coverage across the country without racking up huge travel costs or having to stay away from home. Around 95% of what we look at needs a physical site visit – you can't run a moisture test through a computer screen.

The majority of our instructions come from members of the public rather than solicitors.

At the start, we set up a Flooring Inspector website, ran a Google ad campaign, and it all took off from there. We do have some solicitors who use us regularly now, as well as builders and property developers. But most of our work comes from homeowners who need some honest guidance.

Often, the hardest part is trying to explain to people that a court judgement isn't payment. I find people are sometimes overly keen to enter the court process without fully understanding the difference. I always try and present this clearly to clients and recommend that if they can reach a settlement without involving court action they'll usually be better off.

The cases are very varied – it can be anything from a shedding carpet to a failed subfloor.

The cause of the problem is normally human error rather than a bad product. It's very rare that we come across an actual product fault; it's usually that something hasn't been used, or hasn't been used properly.

Being instructed by a solicitor is different to being instructed by a member of the public.

Cases that come via a solicitor have generally got further down the litigation chain, so relationships between the parties are less cordial. It doesn't matter to me whose fault it is, or whether the floor has to be ripped up. I’m just there to see the situation and report on it.

When I’m contacted by a member of the public, they'll often start off with a line like "I just want to make sure I'm not going mad." They know very little about the subject – often it’s obvious that they’ve used AI to research and write their email to us. But, while AI can be very useful for certain aspects, a lot of the time the quality of the information produced is based on the quality of the information input – so it's not accurate or relevant.

Ultimately, people just need some independent guidance, and that’s where I come in. I try and keep things as simple as possible. I obviously need to use certain terminology and jargon as I write technical reports, but I try to make these as easy to read and understand as possible.

A lot of clients have no experience of the legal system — another reason I always advise that if they can reach a settlement then they should. It's not a quick process and it's very stressful.

The EWI's cross-examination training prepared me for the courtroom.

I have to attend tribunals and be cross-examined, and I don’t find it too bad. As long as you know what you're talking about and you're being honest, there's nothing to fear.

You can see when a barrister is trying to steer you towards a certain answer, but the EWI provides a lot of helpful training on cross-examination technique. It's the barrister’s job to find a hole to pick at, and it's our job as Experts to make sure things stay on track.

One case in Oxford has stuck with me.

It involved a large, prestigious house builder and a family who'd spent a lot of money on a new house, only to have flooring problems for two years while being ignored and fobbed off with excuses.

After I produced my report, the builder asked for a site meeting – and turned up with seven people, which was clearly some kind of intimidation tactic. I told them whoever needed to be there could stay, and the rest could go back to work.

In the end, the family got a full refund for the entire installation. That was probably the most memorable case from the past year – not for any technical reason, but for the sheer scale of the tactics and the sense of justice.

Attention to detail is one of the most important qualities in an Expert.

You need real, in-depth knowledge of your trade, from a theoretical, technical and practical point of view. If you've never fitted a floor, it's hard to understand why someone might have done something a certain way.

You also need the ability to stay calm, and stick to your guns – clients sometimes want to write the report for you, and you have to be able to say no. Ultimately, it's an independent report, not theirs to dictate.

On the report writing itself: my advice is not to write it and email it off in one motion. Write it, come back to it an hour later, proof it, and make sure every bit of evidence you need is in there.

What I enjoy most about being an Expert Witness is being a part of justice being done.

The satisfying part is to see cases conclude with a just outcome for the parties, such as the outcome in the case of the flooring installation in Oxford I mentioned earlier.  

Expert Witness work is slowly taking over from contracting for me.

I still have a contracting business, but my aim is for the Expert Witness side to become full-time within the next 12 months.

The flooring trade doesn't evolve as much as other fields, which makes it easier to keep up to date.

New adhesives come along, and power tools have replaced hand saws, but people still fit a wood floor much as they did 50 years ago and vinyl is still cut with a knife. Unlike a field such as medicine, the fundamentals don't change much, so it's not too hard to stay on top of developments. I read trade publications and I'm a member of the National Institute of Carpet and Floorlayers, which sends out regular bulletins.

My advice to anyone considering becoming an Expert Witness is…

Get a good website, and make sure your reports look professional. That's where the repeat work will come from.

Join the EWI and do their courses.  You’re likely very knowledgeable about your field, but you need to learn about how you relay that knowledge and make sure your reports are compliant.

If you're a trade contractor thinking of doing Expert Witness work, set it up as a separate business, otherwise it can never be seen as impartial.

There's no such thing as a typical day, and that's something I've had to get used to.

Moving from contracting to Expert Witness work is almost like starting a new career, and establishing a routine has been the hardest part. I'm trying to keep two days a week office-based for admin and report writing, otherwise it's easy to get too reactive and end up with eight reports still to write by the end of the week.

Beyond that, the days are as varied as the clients – London one day, Birmingham the next; a hospital one day, someone's kitchen the next. That variety is something I've always liked about this industry. People also treat you differently as an Expert Witness compared with being a tradesperson – there's an automatic trust and respect that comes with the job, which makes for a nice change after 30 years on the tools.

 

Share

Print
Comments are only visible to subscribers.