Podcast Episode 32: Expert Evidence in the Criminal Courts Podcast Episode 32: Expert Evidence in the Criminal Courts

Podcast Episode 32: Expert Evidence in the Criminal Courts

This month on the podcast we discuss some recent developments in the provision of expert evidence in the criminal courts, look at the results of our...
A Day in the Life of a Flooring Expert Witness A Day in the Life of a Flooring Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of a Flooring Expert Witness

Rob Kilner has spent nearly 30 years in the flooring industry, running his own contracting and restoration business across the UK. He founded Flooring...
Alleged delays in treating suspected cauda equina syndrome Alleged delays in treating suspected cauda equina syndrome

Alleged delays in treating suspected cauda equina syndrome

Mrs Griffiths alleged that delays in treating suspected cauda equina syndrome in 2017 caused lasting neurological injury. The claim failed on...
At 30, EWI looks forward to 2030 At 30, EWI looks forward to 2030

At 30, EWI looks forward to 2030

EWI Celebrates 30th anniversary with launch of new Strategy.
Civil Justice Council’s Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents: Final Report Civil Justice Council’s Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents: Final Report

Civil Justice Council’s Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents: Final Report

The Civil Justice Council (‘CJC’) has published its final report on the ‘Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents’ (‘Report’). With regard to expert...
EWI welcomes three new Board Members EWI welcomes three new Board Members

EWI welcomes three new Board Members

Following their appointment at the AGM in June, the EWI is delighted to welcome Karen Addy, Max Beckett, and James Eade to the Board of Governors.
The combative paediatric expert remains anonymous The combative paediatric expert remains anonymous

The combative paediatric expert remains anonymous

In this case the judge had a number of criticisms of the expert paediatrician and as a result there was a subsequent hearing to consider whether to...
Craigard (Dartford) Limited & Anor v Westbury Homes (Holdings) Limited & Anor [2026] EWHC... Craigard (Dartford) Limited & Anor v Westbury Homes (Holdings) Limited & Anor [2026] EWHC...

Craigard (Dartford) Limited & Anor v Westbury Homes (Holdings) Limited & Anor [2026] EWHC...

The case dealt with the claim by the landlord for breach of the tenant’s covenants and conditions following the expiry of the tenant’s lease on an...
Podcast Episode 31: 30 years of Expert Evidence Podcast Episode 31: 30 years of Expert Evidence

Podcast Episode 31: 30 years of Expert Evidence

This month we have a special episode to celebrate 30 years since the Expert Witness Institute was launched on 8 November 2026. We are going to look...
A Day in the Life of an Oil and Commodities Expert Witness A Day in the Life of an Oil and Commodities Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of an Oil and Commodities Expert Witness

Catherine Jago is an oil and commodities Expert Witness with nearly four decades of experience in the field. She started her career at BP before...
Podcast Episode 30: Mapping the Expert Witness Workforce Podcast Episode 30: Mapping the Expert Witness Workforce

Podcast Episode 30: Mapping the Expert Witness Workforce

This month on the Expert Matters Podcast, Simon and EWI's Membership Manager, Will Watkiss, discuss the EWI's project to map the Expert Witness...
A Day in the Life of an Occupational Therapy Expert Witness A Day in the Life of an Occupational Therapy Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of an Occupational Therapy Expert Witness

Clare Cole is an Occupational Therapist with nearly 17 years of clinical experience, who now works as an Expert Witness in the medico-legal field....

Check out our Case Updates and Member Magazine

Looking for more news relevant to the Expert Witness community? Why not check out our database of cases relevant to Expert Evidence or the latest and previous editions of our member magazine, Expert Matters.

News

Clicking on one of the topics below will display news items relevant to that topic. You can also use the search bar below to identify news items.

Kamran Safi v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] EWCA Civ 149
Sean Mosby 1671

Kamran Safi v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] EWCA Civ 149

by Sean Mosby

 

Summary

The Secretary of State for the Home Office was appealing the decision of the First Tier Tribunal (‘FTT’) to allow the Respondent’s appeal on Article 2 and 3 ECHR grounds against his deportation to Afghanistan. The Home Office did not seek to challenge the Respondent’s experts by requiring either of the experts to attend for cross-examination.

Learning points for instructing parties

  • If you chose to neither serve your own expert evidence nor cross-examine the opposing party’s experts, you are likely to face difficulties putting forward arguments contrary to what the experts have written.

The case

The Secretary of State for the Home Office was appealing the decision of the First Tier Tribunal (‘FTT’) to allow the Respondent’s appeal on Article 2 and 3 ECHR grounds against his deportation to Afghanistan. The decision was appealed, initially to the Upper Tribunal (‘UT), and then to the Court of Appeal.

Expert evidence

The Respondent served “a substantial body of carefully argued expert evidence” at the FTT direction hearing, particularly expert reports from Mr F and Dr P. The judge noted that, in this case, the Home Office did not lose because of any general finding that adult male Afghans who are convicted of a serious offence in this country cannot be deported to Afghanistan, but because it did not seek to challenge the Respondent’s experts by requiring either of the experts to attend for cross-examination. “In those circumstances”, the judge noted, “the [Home Office Presenting Officer] was inevitably in difficulties in putting forward arguments contrary to what the experts had written: see TUI UK Ltd v Griffiths [2025] AC 374 [2023] UKSC 48 at [70].

Th expert report of Dr P stated that:

“Based on my professional expertise, I conclude that if Mr Safi were removed to Afghanistan, he would be at a high risk of being re-trafficked since there are several indicators ranging from his young age, sexual abuse, route to Europe and criminalisation that demonstrate he is a potential victim of trafficking. Moreover, his state of mental health and the lack of mental health infrastructure in the country makes him more vulnerable to be re-trafficked. […] All these factors demonstrate that there is more than a plausible risk of persecution for Mr Safi if he were removed to Afghanistan.”

Dr P also stated that vulnerable men have been significantly more susceptible to being exploited, abused and forced into labour since the Taliban's rise to power in August 202

Mr F's evidence was that the degree of Mr Safi's Westernisation gave substantial grounds for believing that there is a real risk of mistreatment which would breach Article 3.

The judge concluded that “[i]t may be that some of these conclusions, particularly on the consequences of Westernisation, could have been subjected to challenge in the FTT, but the judge had to deal with the case on the basis that there was little if any challenge. In those circumstances, in agreement with the UT, I do not consider that in accepting the expert evidence, particularly that which was specific to the Respondent, the FTT made any error of law.”

Judge’s decision

The judge agreed with the UT that the FTT’s reasoning was sufficient to indicate why the appeal was allowed, noting that the FTT judge had to decide, “on the evidence placed before him”, whether there was a real risk on return of Mr Safi being killed (Article 2) or subjected to inhuman or degrading treatment (Article 3).

 

 

Share

Print
Comments are only visible to subscribers.