Podcast Episode 32: Expert Evidence in the Criminal Courts Podcast Episode 32: Expert Evidence in the Criminal Courts

Podcast Episode 32: Expert Evidence in the Criminal Courts

This month on the podcast we discuss some recent developments in the provision of expert evidence in the criminal courts, look at the results of our...
A Day in the Life of a Flooring Expert Witness A Day in the Life of a Flooring Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of a Flooring Expert Witness

Rob Kilner has spent nearly 30 years in the flooring industry, running his own contracting and restoration business across the UK. He founded Flooring...
Alleged delays in treating suspected cauda equina syndrome Alleged delays in treating suspected cauda equina syndrome

Alleged delays in treating suspected cauda equina syndrome

Mrs Griffiths alleged that delays in treating suspected cauda equina syndrome in 2017 caused lasting neurological injury. The claim failed on...
At 30, EWI looks forward to 2030 At 30, EWI looks forward to 2030

At 30, EWI looks forward to 2030

EWI Celebrates 30th anniversary with launch of new Strategy.
Civil Justice Council’s Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents: Final Report Civil Justice Council’s Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents: Final Report

Civil Justice Council’s Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents: Final Report

The Civil Justice Council (‘CJC’) has published its final report on the ‘Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents’ (‘Report’). With regard to expert...
EWI welcomes three new Board Members EWI welcomes three new Board Members

EWI welcomes three new Board Members

Following their appointment at the AGM in June, the EWI is delighted to welcome Karen Addy, Max Beckett, and James Eade to the Board of Governors.
The combative paediatric expert remains anonymous The combative paediatric expert remains anonymous

The combative paediatric expert remains anonymous

In this case the judge had a number of criticisms of the expert paediatrician and as a result there was a subsequent hearing to consider whether to...
Craigard (Dartford) Limited & Anor v Westbury Homes (Holdings) Limited & Anor [2026] EWHC... Craigard (Dartford) Limited & Anor v Westbury Homes (Holdings) Limited & Anor [2026] EWHC...

Craigard (Dartford) Limited & Anor v Westbury Homes (Holdings) Limited & Anor [2026] EWHC...

The case dealt with the claim by the landlord for breach of the tenant’s covenants and conditions following the expiry of the tenant’s lease on an...
Podcast Episode 31: 30 years of Expert Evidence Podcast Episode 31: 30 years of Expert Evidence

Podcast Episode 31: 30 years of Expert Evidence

This month we have a special episode to celebrate 30 years since the Expert Witness Institute was launched on 8 November 2026. We are going to look...
A Day in the Life of an Oil and Commodities Expert Witness A Day in the Life of an Oil and Commodities Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of an Oil and Commodities Expert Witness

Catherine Jago is an oil and commodities Expert Witness with nearly four decades of experience in the field. She started her career at BP before...
Podcast Episode 30: Mapping the Expert Witness Workforce Podcast Episode 30: Mapping the Expert Witness Workforce

Podcast Episode 30: Mapping the Expert Witness Workforce

This month on the Expert Matters Podcast, Simon and EWI's Membership Manager, Will Watkiss, discuss the EWI's project to map the Expert Witness...
A Day in the Life of an Occupational Therapy Expert Witness A Day in the Life of an Occupational Therapy Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of an Occupational Therapy Expert Witness

Clare Cole is an Occupational Therapist with nearly 17 years of clinical experience, who now works as an Expert Witness in the medico-legal field....

Check out our Case Updates and Member Magazine

Looking for more news relevant to the Expert Witness community? Why not check out our database of cases relevant to Expert Evidence or the latest and previous editions of our member magazine, Expert Matters.

News

Clicking on one of the topics below will display news items relevant to that topic. You can also use the search bar below to identify news items.

Experts who rise above the fray and fully discharge their duties to assist the Court
Sean Mosby 1355

Experts who rise above the fray and fully discharge their duties to assist the Court

by Sean Mosby

 

Summary

The case concerned around 40 studio recordings of performances which were given by the members of the Jimi Hendrix Experience. The expert witnesses in New York law were commended by the judge on their written and oral evidence. The judge was not persuaded by any of the criticisms of the claimants' expert made by the defendant.  

Learning points

Learning points for experts
  • Your expertise is your best defence against criticism by the opposing party.

  • As the judge in this case noted, exercising your expertise effectively includes:

    • producing detailed reports, which read well and are clearly the product of hard work and thorough research,

    • displaying expertise in both your written and oral evidence, and

    • being clearly aware of your duties to the court and seeking to assist the judge to the best of your ability.

Learning points for instructing parties
  • When criticising the opposing expert, it may be wisest to base those criticisms on an objective reading of the quality of the expert’s evidence.

  • Ensure that the material you rely on in making your criticisms supports the criticisms you are making.

 

The case

The case concerned around 40 studio recordings of performances which were given by the members of the Jimi Hendrix Experience, a band formed in 1968 between James ‘Jimi’ Hendirx, on guitar and vocals, David Noel Redding, on bass and John Graham ‘Mitch’ Mitchell, on drums.

The central questions in the action were:

  1. The ownership of the copyrights in recordings the studio performances made between 1966 and 1968, and

  2. The ownership of the performers’ property rights in relation to the participation of, respectively, Mr Redding and Mr Mitchell in the performances.

The expert witnesses

Both parties were given permission to adduce evidence from one expert in the field of New York law.

The claimants called Mr C, an attorney who specialised in complex commercial litigation, often concerning issues of contact law, copyright and civil procedure. The defendant called Professor K, the Alfred McCormack Professor of Law and a full-time faculty member at Columbia Law School. The experts each prepared a principal report, shorter second reports, and a joint statement, recording their areas of agreement and disagreement.

The judge was impressed by both experts and found their evidence to be helpful. In particular, he noted that they both:

  • produced detailed reports, which read well and were clearly products of hard work and thorough research,

  • displayed considerable expertise in both their written and oral evidence, and

  • were clearly aware of their duties to the court and were seeking to assist the judge to the best of their ability.

The judge agreed with the submission by the claimants' counsel that “the case was a model example of how, even in hard-fought cases (as this has been), experts can rise above the fray and fully discharge their duties to assist the Court.” He accepted the invitation of the claimants' counsel to commend both of the experts on their written and oral evidence.

The criticism of Mr C

In their closing submissions, the defendant’s counsel attacked the credibility of Mr C, characterising his evidence as having “raised a number of concerns”. The alleged failures in his expert evidence included:

  1. misunderstanding his role as an independent expert,

  2. frequently slipping into arguing his case for his instructing clients,

  3. selective quotation,

  4. having a tendency to misconstrue the New York authorities to which he referred,

  5. attempting to fashion new arguments which were not in his expert report,

  6. giving speeches in the manner of an advocate,

  7. adopting positions which favoured the Claimants, and

  8. refusing to give ground when he should have done.

The judge was not persuaded by any of these criticisms and preferred the submissions of the claimants' counsel in his overall assessment of the experts. The criticisms were at odds with the judge’s own reading of Mr C’s reports and the impressions he formed when hearing oral evidence. They were also not borne out by the material the defendant relied upon in support of its criticisms. The judge highlighted some non-exhaustive examples of such material which did not bear out the criticism made of Mr C including:

  • The defendant’s counsel accused Mr C, in their written closing submissions, of ignoring key premises of the reasoning in two New York cases. In the judge’s view, this was not a fair criticism. It was clear from Mr C’s written evidence, and his evidence in cross-examination, that he had not ignored any key premises. Rather he had considered the relevant case law and come to a view.

  • In support of their accusation that Mr C made speeches in the manner of an advocate the defendant’s counsel, in their written closing submissions, referred to the use by Mr C, in his oral evidence, of the image of a spectrum to illustrate his point that releases fell into a category of contracts. The judge found the image of spectrum to be useful in understanding what Mr C was saying, and noted that a spectrum, or a sliding scale, is a routine part of lawyer’s language when describing a particular principle of law. The judge could not detect a hint of an advocate making a speech in this or any other part of Mr C’s evidence.

The judge’s conclusion

The judge found that Professor K was generally better able, particularly in his oral evidence, to identify and explain the principles of New York law, and also explain why he favoured a particular view of the law on points where there was a lack of clear guidance in New York law. However, the judge noted that this did not cause him to think that Professor K was necessarily right, and Mr C necessarily wrong, on any particular point in issue between the experts.

Drawing together all his analysis on the expert evidence, the judge decided that he should not prefer the evidence of one expert over the other, in relation to issues between the experts. Instead, he had to decide whose view to prefer in relation to each such issue, drawing on the evidence of New York law provided to him by the experts.

 

Share

Print
Comments are only visible to subscribers.